But the liberal consensus was fraying around them, and liberal and leftist action came apart once again. Moderate groups pressed leftists to tone down their tactics, demands and rhetoric. They insisted, for example, that SNCC, the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, remove the militant language from its speech at the March on Washington so as not to alienate the president and the liberal legislators needed to pass civil rights laws.
By the mid-1960s, to many on the left, especially the young, liberalism seemed to have failed the movement, and in egregious ways. There were no federal protections for people engaged in legal activity like registering to vote. Attacks on civil rights activists went unpunished. At the 1964 Democratic National Convention, that supposedly liberal party refused to seat the integrated Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party, which had grown out of Freedom Summer, in place of a delegation chosen in an illegal all-white primary. And Martin Luther King Jr. was attacked in Chicago, the bastion of Northern liberalism.
Those disappointments fueled Black nationalism and Black Power on the Black left. SNCC and CORE became all-Black, and the Black Panthers rose. You cannot trust white liberals, they argued, because when forced to choose between their whiteness and their liberalism, as at the 1964 convention, they chose whiteness. They also criticized liberalism’s commitment to integration as both unachievable and a kind of cultural genocide, since racism would supposedly end only when Black people acted like white people.
More subtly (and this is more my own theory), the left’s understanding of racism shifted, and with it the sense of who Black people’s natural allies were. The older view had linked hatred of Black people and of Jews as products of the same pseudoscience, the biological falsehood that certain peoples were inferior. The New Left concluded instead that racism grew out of capitalism and state power. That tied together the experiences of people of color around the world and focused attention on institutional racism and on European colonialism. So the left split. Black Power activists turned away from treating racism and antisemitism as linked and toward alliance with other people of color worldwide.
Many white Jews and most white organizations, liberal rather than leftist, fundamentally misunderstood the frustration and anger behind these moves. They saw them not just as tactical errors but as an unfair, even racist or antisemitic, rejection of their efforts: nationalism and separatism felt like a wound to the heart. Many progressive Jews, on the other hand, celebrated Black nationalism and modeled their own activism on it, calling it Jewish power. Turning to their own community as the Panthers had, they fought for Soviet Jewry and for Jewish studies programs alongside the Black studies programs Black students were demanding. They kept the leftist arguments, but moved away from a coalition built around racism and traditional civil rights.
In 1967, SNCC criticized Israel’s treatment of Palestinians as part of a global struggle of people of color against colonialism. Leftist Jews understood. Liberal and mainstream Jews saw antisemitism and withdrew their support. Had they understood the anger and frustration behind it, and the shifting focus on European powers oppressing indigenous peoples of color, they could still have disagreed without taking it as a personal attack. Instead, they demanded that SNCC defer to Jewish concerns before they would help with its civil rights struggle, and reminded Black leaders of all that Jews had done for them. SNCC’s statement, Harry Golden wrote, “comes with ill grace from an organization from which two Jewish boys were murdered while doing field work for SNCC.” Jewish financial support for SNCC plummeted.
Refusing to aid SNCC because of its support for Palestinians again shows the effects of invisible white privilege. Without realizing it, Jewish groups saw themselves more as benefactors than as partners. If they didn’t get their way, they would withdraw support from the cause SNCC represented.